Ep. 274 - Inside the NXIVM Cult: Sarah Edmondson's Story - PT 1
f you think you’d never fall for a cult, let's take a closer look.
The NXIVM cult didn’t lure the weak — it attracted smart, curious, ambitious people looking for growth and belonging. People just like us.
And right in the middle of it was Sarah Edmondson, a high-ranking member who helped blow it wide open in The New York Times and HBO’sThe Vow.
In this conversation, we unpack how something that looked like empowerment turned into manipulation — and how the need to belong can become a weapon.
Sarah shares what actually happened inside NXIVM, how coercive control disguised itself as “self-improvement,” and the exact moment she realized she was part of something dark.
We talk about the psychology that keeps smart people compliant, the power structures that mirrored everyday life, and what breaking free really cost her.
It’s part cult exposé, part human study — and all about reclaiming your voice when someone else has tried to own it.
What You’ll Learn in This Episode
How the NXIVM cult disguised coercive control as personal growth
The psychology of belonging and why smart people get trapped
The moment Sarah Edmondson decided to blow it all open
How language and hierarchy keep people obedient without force
What the NXIVM story teaches us about modern cults and power
Resources Mentioned
The Vow(HBO docuseries)
Scarredby Sarah Edmondson(book)
Podcast:A Little Bit Culty hosted by Sarah Edmondson & Nippy Ames
Pre-Order New Book; A Little Bit Culty
Sarah Edmondson’s website –sarahedmondson.com
Quotes (from Sarah Edmondson)
“Cults don’t prey on weakness — they prey on hope.” 09:2409:2409:24
“I didn’t wake up and think, ‘Oh God, I’m in a cult.’ It was a slow drip of trust and fear.” 15:0215:0215:02
“The brand became my evidence. It was the proof we weren’t crazy.” 27:1827:1827:18
“I had to reclaim my story before someone else told it for me.” 34:4534:4534:45
“Once you understand coercive control, you start seeing it everywhere.” 42:1142:1142:11
Timestamps (Key Moments)
0:00 Intro – How NXIVM hooked smart people
5:40 Sarah joins NXIVM and finds community
12:55 The early red flags everyone missed
22:18 The branding and Sarah’s breaking point
30:04 The New York Times story that blew it open
42:00 The psychology of control and obedience
52:33 Outro – Reclaiming power after indoctrination
Tips / Takeaways
Belonging is a human need — and that’s what makes it so exploitable.
Coercive control often sounds like self-improvement until you question it.
Recovery starts with reclaiming your own definition of truth and power.
Want to know your Podcast Personality Type? Take the free quiz at allisonhare.com/personality —it’s freakishly accurate and will show you how to create connection-driven content that fits you.
And if you’re ready to build a show that fuels your brand and attracts your dream clients, book a free clarity call atallisonhare.com/freecall.
What kind of support would you like for your podcast growth and success?
Connect with me on Instagram, LinkedIn, or visit my website to continue this conversation about building the communities we desperately need.
Allison Hare's Links
Be sure to rate, review, and follow this podcast on your player and also, connect with me IRL for more goodness and life-changing stuff.
Schedule a FREE podcast clarity call with me - Your future audience is out there. Talk to them!
DOWNLOAD the free podcast equipment guide- No guesswork, no google rabbit holes, start recording today
Reb3l Dance Fitness - Try it at home! Free month with this link.
Personal Brand - need help building yours? Schedule a call with me here and let's discuss.
Feedback and Contact:: [email protected]
